The usual Monday Criticism plan rarely comes to student plan, in particular, was happy when I received the following. The simple fact is that too was happy to be at first glance did not see a conventional building.

I do not know who was selected by lot, but I managed to find one that you can be quite difficult to integrate well. To be sure, who would create such a plot would opt for the actual installation, if not the right kind of bezárkózós, so here it is difficult to find a smooth place on it.

I received the following letter:

Dear Lord Koos!
I am a college student of architecture, building design and building subjects made ​​my opinion I would like to send. If you find it worthwhile, it can be published on the website.

The corner into the above is quite good and the crowd followed by the formation of well-built little contour area.

The floor plan is well take advantage of the benefits arising from sarokelrendezésből so different sides can be approached on foot and by car. If we interpret the drawings of the Northern signal is "upward" in the north (?). This is interesting because of the orientation space can be judged in this light.

As a student back then we also had a separate genre to create your own North, as if it was some kind of business. It was unbelievable how well we can megkomplikálni, kicifrázni this simple function symbol to a judge. But I will never forget that to be completely clear, as it is graphic statutes.

The floor plan layout - especially the front-kitchen-dining-living room combination is sufficiently generous and spacious, well-standing fireplace in the space separating the functions. Should specifically highlight the entrance, which is much more pronounced in the usual and framed, not just a door on the facade.

What these observations to separate the toilet just before the passing of the bedrooms, the family's intimate zone to be reached. I do not know the design program, but if you are not a specific claim (family) are concerned, most builders require szeparáltságot.

The other complaint I have relates to the bedroom. It is still okay, that the northern facing master bedroom, but difficult to defend the two children's rooms clean NE orientation (the one with south-eastern orientation could have been provided). The best orientation is currently in the garage, which is almost from morning through orientation, késődélutánig benapozott will .... which is not required at this helyiségnél, but not the gyerekszobáknál.

If the orientation may be reversed, that is, North is down - which is unusual, because the site layout is always portrayed that on top - then of course the above is not true.

This includes the fact that a building is exposed to so much insight, the direction of the street may be less fortunate betervezni parapet without windows. In addition hálószobákról is where the expectation is of particular importance zavartalanság. If your child's room is not from the NE, but the garage swapped places, would be aligned to the SW, then these szobáknál this problem also disappear.

Such a handsomely designed buildings - but today it is a normal family house - very often two-point demands of the garage, which would fit well here, I really should not have much to add to the existing width.

Which is clearly good, the shape of the building mass. The proportions are good, well structured and varied, perhaps too much so. Both the plan and in reality they look good in the glass block hole-like surfaces, the work has aggályosabb, such amount is already a very serious extent they should be considered an energy calculation.

Summary | students do worse than plan, good to see how they can in other ways to approach this design is both easy and difficult task. Pleasure to see this fresh, which fortunately did not go to the expense of function. The nets correct orientation and placement of the toilet of a customer to an actual consultation would very likely anyway in a few buildings and burnt after the right solution for a designer's mind. Congratulations to the plan!

If you would like to show to others in the preparation / completion of the apartment or house, or curious as to what others say about the house you like, you can send it to us , and of course, we present our opinion as to say it. If your house is not yours, but curious what others think about it, it can be submitted electronically. Discretion is because you can do all this anonymously, of course, up to the city (+ district) entering.

And ... What do you think?

the designer of what you made ​​mistakes?

• own "model plans" tried to sell
• Slave mode only planned or signed
• did not allow for the ideas - self-contained formalism
• only eng. plan undertaken
• unreliability
• failed to consult with the authorities
• you planned, there could be authorized
• 3D designs did not
• could not be built
• költségérzéketlenség

Results

Loading ...

If you liked this writing, sign up for email értesítőnkre

10 posts in "Design Criticism 28 | a college plan"